How to solve Calcudoku
Calcudoku is a square grid cut into cages. Every row and every column holds the digits from 1 up to the size of the grid, each once, and every cage has a target and a sign in its corner: added up, multiplied, or, in a cage of two cells, subtracted or divided, its digits have to make that target. The same puzzle is also known as KenKen.
Nothing here is a hint: the board never checks you against the answer, and none of the moves below needs it to. These six techniques are the whole ladder the boards are graded on, simplest first, each drawn on a small board you can step through at your own pace.
How to play
Fill the grid so that every row and every column holds the digits from 1 up to the size of the grid, each exactly once: on a 5 × 5, that is 1 to 5.
The heavy outlines are cages. The number in a cage’s corner is its target, and the sign beside it says how the cage’s digits make it: added up with +, multiplied with ×.
A cage with − or ÷ has two cells: the larger digit less the smaller, or the larger divided by the smaller, gives the target, and either cell may hold the larger. A cage of one cell holds its number.
A digit may repeat within a cage, but only in cells that share no row and no column.
No digit is given. The cages are enough: there is exactly one solution, and it never needs a guess.
Tap a cell and pick a digit on the pad under the board; the same digit again clears it. With notes on, digits are pencilled small in the cell instead. Under the pad are the sets of digits the selected cell’s cage can be made of; a set that no longer fits the digits you have written in the cage is faded.
On the 9 × 9, two fingers zoom and move the board; while it is zoomed, a little map beside the buttons moves it too. A single tap always picks a cell.
A reddish cell holds a digit its row or column already has, or belongs to a cage whose digits can no longer make its target, and that cage’s label turns red too. A cage’s label and outline grey out once the cage is full, makes its target and none of its cells is reddish.
Every board has exactly one solution, and it can be reached without a single guess. A 5 × 5 needs only the first two techniques below; a 7 × 7 needs the third as well, and now and then the fourth; a 9 × 9 needs the fifth or the sixth besides. Most of what follows comes from two facts: a target and its sign allow only a few sets of digits, and a row or column never holds a digit twice, so once a digit is written in a cell, no other cell of its row or its column can take it.
What a cage can hold
A cage’s label is its target and its sign, and together they allow only certain digits:
- With + the digits add up to the target and with × they multiply to make it, in a cage of any size.
- With − or ÷ the cage has two cells, and the larger digit less the smaller, or the larger divided by the smaller, is the target, and either cell may hold the larger.
- A cage of one cell has no sign and holds its target.
Each way of filling a cage that makes its target is called a filling, and no filling puts the same digit twice into one row or column. Within a cage a digit may repeat, but only in two cells that share no row and no column, as the two ends of a cage bent round a corner do. A digit that no filling puts in a cell can be struck off that cell. And as the board fills, a cell losing a digit can rule a filling out, so a cage is worth reading again whenever one of its cells changes. On the board, the sets of digits the selected cell’s cage can be made of are listed under the pad.
The last digit, the last place
Two questions, asked again and again, fill the cells in one by one: which digits are left for this cell, and where in this row or column can this digit still go? A cell with one digit left takes it; a digit with one place left in a line goes there. Every digit written rules itself out of the rest of its row and column, and some fillings of the cages around it too, which opens the way for the next. Together with the cages’ fillings, these two moves finish every 5 × 5.
A digit kept to one line
Sometimes a cage tells you which digits it holds but not where. If every filling of a cage puts a certain digit in the same row or column, that line’s one copy of the digit is inside the cage, so no other cell of the line can hold it. A cage lying wholly in one line keeps every digit it must hold to that line; a cage bent round a corner keeps a digit to one arm only when every filling puts it there. Every 7 × 7 needs this, usually several times.
Pairs and triples
When two cells of one row or column are left with the same two digits and nothing else, those two digits are theirs, whichever way round, and no other cell of that line can hold either. Three cells left with three digits between them work the same way. In Calcudoku the two cells of a pair often belong to different cages, which makes the pair easy to miss. A 7 × 7 needs it now and then, not on every board; this small one needs it once.
Line totals
A row or column holds every digit from 1 up to the size of the board once, so its digits always add up to the same total, whatever their order: 10 on a 4 × 4, 15 on a 5 × 5, 28 on a 7 × 7, 45 on a 9 × 9. From that total take away the targets of the adding cages lying wholly inside the line, those of its cages of one cell and any digits already written there: the cells left over have to make up the difference, as if they were a cage of their own. The same goes for the product: every row and column multiplies out to 1 × 2 × … up to the size, 120 on a 5 × 5, and the multiplying cages inside it divide that down. Every 9 × 9 needs this or the next technique at least once, and about half of them this one.
The two-line read
Two lines can be read together. If a digit’s only places in two rows lie in the same two columns, those two columns take that digit in those two rows, one each, whichever way round, so it can be nowhere else in either column. The same holds with rows and columns swapped. In Calcudoku it often comes from two small cages stacked one above the other that must both hold the same digit. Every 9 × 9 needs this or the line totals at least once, and about two in three of them this one.
No timer. Leave and come back — it’s saved.
Play today’s Calcudoku